Lip Gloss vs. Lipstick: Finding Your Perfect Lip Product

By Jami Stansfield

November 07, 2024

Featured Products

Diamond Sparkle Lip Gloss Pack - 5 Pack

$45.00

Get 30% savings and shine bright with our Diamond Sparkle Lip Gloss Pack.

Diamond Lip Gloss

$13.00

Is lip gloss considered a liquid when flying?

Are you planning for a flight and wondering if lip gloss is considered liquid and whether you can take it along with you? As a makeup artist, I understand the importance of lip gloss, especially when travelling, to keep your lips looking fabulous. Whether you're heading for a normal vacation or a business trip, having that perfect shine on your lips can boost your confidence and enhance your overall look. However, going through airport security regulations can be tricky, especially when it comes to liquids.

Fixing Spray vs Setting Spray: What’s the Difference and When to Use?

Have you ever found yourself staring at the beauty shelves, caught between a fixing spray and a setting spray, unsure which one to choose? I’ve been in that position! As a makeup artist, I’ve tested both of these products countless times, and at first, they seemed pretty similar. Both promise to lock in your makeup for the day, so how do you know which one is right for you?

How Long Does Lip Gloss Last?

As a makeup artist, lip gloss has always been one of my favorite go-to products for creating effortlessly polished looks. It is a versatile beauty staple that adds an irresistible shine and amplifies the natural color of your lips in just seconds. Throughout the years, I've worked with numerous clients, from brides to models, on photoshoots. One of the most common questions I have gotten is: How long does lip gloss last, and how can you keep it looking fresh?

How to Exfoliate Lips: A Complete Guide to Soft, Smooth Lips

Ever wonder why your lip gloss doesn't just glide on, or why your lips are always dry and flaky? Well, let me tell you, as a professional makeup artist, a perfect pout isn't about the products you use; it's about laying the right foundation first. Just like your skin, your lips need the proper care and attention to be soft, smooth, and hydrated.

Is Lip Gloss Bad for Your Lips? A Guide to Healthy & Glossy Lips

Ever wonder if your everyday lip gloss is actually good or bad for your lips? It’s pretty easy to fall in love with that glossy shine and just how it can instantly make a person’s lips look plump and radiant, but have you considered how it affects the delicate skin of your lips? Whether it is an everyday clear gloss or a lip-plumping gloss to make a bold statement, this is a must-have product that most beauty routines need.

Lipglass vs. Lip Gloss: Key Differences and How to Choose

Have you ever wondered what the real difference is between lipglass and lip gloss? As a makeup professional, I often get asked this question, and I can see why it’s a bit confusing. Lip products have certainly come a long way over the years, and no matter whether you are going for a subtle, natural finish or an intense glossy one, there is something for everyone.

When it comes to choosing a lip cosmetic, one of the biggest choices you’ll face is deciding between lip gloss and lipstick. Both have their own unique charm, bringing different finishes, shades, and effects to the table. But which one truly suits your style and needs? As a professional makeup artist, I often recommend that clients think about their desired look and lifestyle before choosing. For instance, if you’re after a long-lasting, richly pigmented colour, matte lipstick might be your best friend. Glossy lipstick has been an obsession among all women for a long time and if you want a fresh, natural look with a hint of shine, lip gloss could be the perfect match.

To help you decide, let's explore the details of lip gloss vs lipstick, breaking down their benefits, finishes, and key differences. We’ll cover everything from matte lipsticks to liquid lipsticks and clear glosses, so you can confidently select the right lip product to achieve your ideal look and feel.

What is Lip Gloss?

Lip gloss is a cosmetic product used to overcome dryness and provide a glossy surface to the lips. It is available in both clear and colored formulas. Lip glosses are generally defined by their watery formulation and luminous shine. They are ideal in the application when one needs to attain a natural look with subtle color and hydrated lips. Many lip glosses are made up of ingredients such as petroleum jelly for shine, although some brands use natural oils and waxes, which makes them quite safe and effective. With so many lip glosses out there, finding one to suit your style and needs is pretty easy.

Benefits of Lip Gloss

Adding Shine: lipgloss works great to add a fresh and youthful touch. The high shine finish reflects the light, hence giving a natural look while complementing your natural lip color.
Hydrating Formulas: Many lip glosses contain hydrating ingredients like shea butter or petroleum jelly that help to keep lips hydrated and comfortable, especially for individuals who have issues with dry lips.
Easy to Apply: Lip gloss is perfect for those who desire low maintenance. Applying lip gloss is quick and doesn’t require the precision of a lip liner or lip pencil.
Variety in Finish and Color: From sheer to highly pigmented options, lip glosses allow for flexibility. You can keep it simple with a clear lip gloss or go bold with a richly pigmented option from your favorite lip gloss collection.

Drawbacks of Lip Gloss

Short-Wear: Most lip glosses won't last throughout the day. They generally require reapplication throughout the day.
Stickiness: It has some stickiness or tackiness. This is one of the world's greatest complaints about glosses. But there are some newer glosses that are designed to be non-sticky.
Transferability: Gloss is a liquid product and tends to easily transfer to cups, masks, and other surfaces.

What is Lipstick?

It is a traditional lip product that offers color, moisture, and long wearability. Made from wax, oil, and pigments, lipstick formulations can vary greatly from brand to brand. Available in finishes, for instance: matte, satin, sheer, and frosted. Unlike lip gloss and lipglass, lipsticks are not glossy or sticky. Even satin or shiny lipsticks won’t have the same type of shine as a lip gloss, making them ideal for those who prefer a more subdued finish.

Benefits of Lipstick

Highly Pigmented: Lipstick is considered worthwhile because of its high pigmentation color. Whether in a classic matte finish or creamy satin, lipstick is a wonderful choice if you want that hot pout with bold color.
Variety of Finishes: From matte to glossy lipsticks, they come in many finishes that give a range of generalized looks. For instance, matte lipstick is quite an elegant look while a satin finish is softer with a slight shine.
Long-Lasting: Many lipsticks are formulated to be worn for long. Liquid lipstick and lip stains often outlive gloss, so they work great for events.
Precision and Definition: Using a lip liner or lip pencil with lipstick helps to define and shape the lips, creating a clean, defined look that many find flattering.

Drawbacks of Lipstick

Drying Effect: Some of the matte lipsticks tend to be a bit drying, especially if they lack moisturizing ingredients. Adding a lip balm underneath can help keep lips comfortable.
Potential to Emphasize Lip Texture: Matte and highly pigmented lipsticks can sometimes highlight lines or dryness on the lips. For a smooth finish, it’s helpful to exfoliate and hydrate your lips beforehand, especially if you’re going for a matte or semi-matte finish.
More Complex Application: Compared to gloss, lipstick often requires a steadier hand and sometimes a lip liner to avoid feathering and smudging.

Lip Gloss vs. Lipstick: Key Differences

Even though both products target the area of the lips, they are rather different in formulation, functionality, and purpose. Here's a deeper look into their key differences:

Feature	Lipgloss	lipstick
Texture	The lip glosses are commonly thicker and have a shiny sticky feeling.	Lipsticks, especially matte versions, have a drier texture that can be highly pigmented and velvety.
Wear Time	Glosses are easier to touch up on the go, and generally need reapplication every few hours, as it transfers more easily. For all-day events, a matte or long-wear lipstick is often preferred.	Lipsticks, like liquid lipsticks and matte finish lipsticks, are designed for longer wear and can withstand hours without fading.
Pigmentation	While glosses can be sheer or lightly tinted, for a subtly enhanced natural lip color rather than overpowering it.	Lipsticks provide intense, richly pigmented color that allows for a bold, defined look.
Fragrance and Flavor	Many glosses have subtle fragrances or flavours, adding a sensory appeal but this can be a drawback for those with sensitivities.	Lipsticks have a more neutral scent, especially in matte and long-wear formulas.
Transfer and Smudge Resistance	Glosses, especially those with high-shine finishes, are prone to transferring onto cups, masks, and other surfaces, making them a bit messier in comparison.	Matte lipsticks and liquid lipsticks usually have smudge-resistance and transfer resistance levels better than glosses.
Effect on Lip Volume	Due to its shiny texture, lip gloss is often chosen to make lips look fuller and more voluminous due to its reflective finish.	In contrast, matte lipsticks provide a more defined, sculpted look without adding extra volume.
Moisture and Comfort	Lip glosses are often formulated with moisturizing ingredients like hyaluronic acid and glycerin, making them an excellent choice for dry or chapped lips. They provide a hydrating, glossy finish that keeps your lips looking plump and youthful.	Lipsticks can also be moisturizing, especially those with creamy or satin finishes. However, some matte formulas may be drying, so it’s essential to look for lipsticks that include hydrating ingredients like shea butter or vitamin E.
Finish	Lip gloss creates a glossy or high shine finish, ideal for shiny lips that catch the light and give a youthful glow.	Lipsticks come in a range of finishes, including matte for a sophisticated look, satin for a softer sheen, and even metallic for a bold, reflective effect making it highly versatile.

Lip Gloss vs. Lipstick: When to Use Each

Casual Days: Lip gloss is great for that natural look that has some color and shine, making it just right for casual days or laid-back weekends.

Events and Long Days: Lipstick does just fine, especially in matte, for events, occasions, or when days are so tight one does not even have time to touch up.

Winter and Hydration: Most glosses are mixed with moisturizing elements, making them great for winter months and adding hydration to prevent the lips from feeling dry.

Bold Color Statement: If you want an intense look, or rather catching; use lipstick, offering full pigmentation while it adds boldness to your style.

The Shine: Lip gloss delivers a high-shine effect, ideal for creating full, glossy lips or layering over lipstick for added dimension and sparkle.

Day-to-Night Transitions: Lipstick is quite good for day-to-night transitions because you can wear it matte in the daytime and add just a touch of gloss to get ready for the evening.

[Recommended to read: Lip Oil vs Lip Gloss]

Conclusion: lipgloss or lipstick which is Right For You?

Ultimately, your choice between lip gloss vs lipstick depends on your personal preference, lifestyle, and what kind of appearance you want. But if you're looking to add just shiny, nourishing, low-commitment cosmetic items, then lip gloss can be great for you. For bold lip colors and longer wear with a more dramatic effect, lipstick is the go-to. Remember, you do not have to limit yourself to just one-you can mix and layer gloss and lipstick to create unique looks and textures perfect for any occasion.

FAQs:

Does lipgloss or lipstick last longer?

Generally , lipstick-especially matte and long-wear formulas-last longer than lip gloss. Since it's lighter and shinier, lip gloss tends to wear off faster and have to be re-touched several times throughout the day.

Can Lipgloss cause dark lips?

Yes, most lip glosses are harmless and won't darken the lips. However, the continuous use of low-quality and heavily pigmented glosses without removal may, after some time, cause pigmentation problems. Always clean off your makeup and consider using a lip balm with SPF for protection of the lips.

Do you put on lipgloss or lipstick first?

It depends on the look you want! Typically, lipstick goes first to provide a solid base color, and then lip gloss over the top adds shine and volume. When put together, these can help increase the intensity of the color and leave a long-lasting, very glossy finish.

Who should not wear lipgloss?

Lip gloss might not be ideal for people looking for long-lasting color, those with very dry lips (unless the gloss has hydrating ingredients), or anyone in windy conditions where hair might stick to their lips. Additionally, those seeking a bold, defined lip shape might prefer lipstick for a more polished look.

About the author

Jami Stanfield, the founder of StansOut Beauty Company, is a renowned makeup artist and beauty expert. With a talent for designing popular beauty products like the StansOut Beauty sponge, Jami shares her knowledge and experiences to provide practical makeup tips.